Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 The Department of Persian Language and Literature, University of Tehran

2 The Department of Persian Language and Literature. University of Tehran.

10.22059/jpl.2025.395937.2311

Abstract

Nāser-e Khosrow has repeatedly boasted of his philosophical knowledge, often dismissing his contemporary poets and dabirs as inferior. Yet, his poetic persona has long overshadowed his reputation as a theologian. Furthermore, due to his historical context and Persian-language corpus, his theological and philosophical ideas have been studied far less than those of his predominantly Arabic-writing predecessors. This disparity stems partly from the marginalization of Persian philosophical texts in classical Islamic scholarship. This paper examines the theological dimensions of his work by comparing his discourse on Substance and Accident—a foundational concept in Aristotelian metaphysics—particularly in Zād al-Musāfir (his most significant philosophical work), with Ibn Sinā’s treatment of the same subject in Dānish-nāma-yi ‘alāyī (the latter’s sole work originally composed in Persian). Through this analysis, we demonstrate how Nāser-i Khusrow strategically engaged with Peripatetic thought to articulate his theological arguments, repurposing its frameworks to advance the Ismailis’ apophatic theology. We contend that the Ismailis’ intellectual disputes with philosophers are rooted in these reinterpretations. By highlighting philosophical reflections on Substance and Accident in his poetry, we argue that his philosophical expertise is inextricable from his poetic identity and that interpreting his verse requires close engagement with his prose—an approach many commentators of his poetry have overlooked or neglected, resulting in fragmented readings of his interdisciplinary legacy

Keywords

Main Subjects

References
Berruin, M. (1971). The concept of substance in the philosophy of Ya'gūb al- Kindi and Avicenna (Ibn Sina). Durham theses: Durham University.
Frank, Richard M. (1967). "Al-ma'nà: Some Reflections on the Technical Meanings of the Term in the Kalâm and Its Use in the Physics of Mu'ammar". Journal of the American Oriental Society 87(3) (Jul.- Sep.), pp. 248-259.
Abul-Ḥasan ‘Alī Ismāl‘īl Al-‘aš‘arī (1980). Die Dogmatischen Lehren der Anhänger des Islam. Herausgegeben von Helmut Ritter. Dritte Auflage. Franz Steiner Press, Beirut. [In Arabic].
Abû Ya’qûb [Isḥāq Ibn Aḥmad] Sejestânî (2019). Kashf al-Maíjûb,Texte persan publié avec une introduction par Henry CORBIN. Institut Français de Recherche en Iran; Editions Tahuri. Téheran. [In Persian].
_____________ (2011). Kitāb al-Maqālīd al-Malakūtiyya. Edited by Ismail Kurban Husein Poonawala. Tunesia: Dār al-Gharb al-Islāmī. [In Arabic].
Ansari Qomi, Hasan (2006). "Falsafe-ye Tabi’i-e Mo’tazelian-e Motarrefi", Ketab-e Mah-e Din, Issue 102-103, pp. 4-17. [In Persian].
Avicenna (1987). Kitāb al Ḥudūd (The Book of Definitions), translated from the Arabic text and notes by Muḥammad Mahdī Fūlādvand, Soroush Press, Tehran. [In Persian].
_________ (2004). Metaphysics ‘Alāʼī’s Encyclopaedia, edited, annotated and introduction by Dr. Mohammad Mo‘in. Society for the National Heritage of Iran and Bu-Ali Sina University, Hamadan. [In Persian].
_________ (2005). The Metaphysics Of The Healing, a parallel English-Arabic text translated, introduced, and annotated by Michael E. Marmura. Brigham Young University, Provo, Utah.
_________ (2013). Isharat va Tanbihat, translation and exposition by H. Malekshahi,  Soroush Press, Tehran. [In Persian and Arabic].
Berruin, M. (1971). The concept of substance in the philosophy of Ya'gūb al- Kindi and Avicenna (Ibn Sina). Durham Theses: Durham University.
Daftary, Farhad (2015). A Short History of the Ismailis: Traditions of a Muslim Community, translated by F. Badreii. Farzan Publishers, Tehran. [In Persian].
_____________ (2018). The Ismailis, Their History and Doctrines, translated into Persian by Fereidoon Badreii. Farzan Publishers, Tehran. [In Persian].
Frank, Richard M. (1967). "Al-ma'nà: Some Reflections on the Technical Meanings of the Term in the Kalâm and Its Use in the Physics of Mu'ammar". Journal of the American Oriental Society 87(3) (Jul.- Sep.), pp. 248-259.
Hunsberger, Alice (2011). Nasir Khosraw: The Ruby of Badakhshan (Nasir-Khusraw: The Diamond in the Mine: An Intellectual Biography), translated in Persian by Fereidoon Badreii. Farzan Publishers, Tehran. [In Persian].
Madelung, Wilferd (1993). "Aspects of Ismaili Theology: The Prophetic Chain and The God Beyond Being", translated by A. Shiri. Kayhân-e Andiše, July-August (49): 97-105. [In Persian].
Mohammad Ibn Sorkh de Nishapour (1955). Commentaire de la Qasida Ismaélienne d’Abu’l-Haitham Jorjani. Texte persan édité avec introduction et esquisse comparative en français par Henry CORBIN wt Moh. MO‘IN. Teheran, Imprimerie de l’institut Franco-Iranien. [In Persian].
Nabilu, Alireza (2011). "Barrasi-e Mo’arezeha-ye Falsafi-e Naser-e Khosrow dar Zad al-Mosaferin", Journal of Philosophical Theological Research. 12(3), serial number: 47: 171-197. [In Persian].
Nasir-e Khosraw (1984). Kitab-e Jami‘ al-Hikmatain (Le Livre Réunissant les Deux Sagesses). Texte Persan édité avec une double Étude Préliminare en français et en Persan pae Henry CORBIN et Moh. MO‘IN. Institut Français de Recherche en Iran, Téheran. [In Persian].
______________ (1989). Dīwān. Edited by M. Minovi & M. Mohaqqeq. University of Tehran. [In Persian].
Qubādīyānī [Marwazī] Balkhī, Nāṣir Khusru (2005). Zād al-Musāfir. Exposition of Words and Terms by S.I. ‘Imādī Ḥā’irī. Edited & Researched by S.M. ‘Imādī Ḥā’irī. Mīrās̠-i Maktūb, Tehran. [In Persian].
_______________ (2018). Xān al-ʼexwān. Edited by S.A. Mir Baqeri Fard & E. Ra’isi. Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran. [In Persian].
_______________ (2011). Gušāyiš u Rahāyiš. Edited by S. Nafisi. Asatir Publications. Tehran. [In Persian].
Rajabi, Mohammadreza  (2001). "Zendegi va Andiše-hâ-ye Naser-e Khosrow" in Ismailism: Collection of Essays, by the Department of Islamic Denominations. University of Religions and Denominations, Qom. [In Persian].
Shahidi, S. Ja‘far (1975). "ʼaqâyed-e Kalâmi-e Nâser-e Khosrow", Yaghmâ, february (318): 705-711. [In Persian].
Walker, Paul Ernest (2000). Ḥamīd al-Din Kirmāni: Ismaili Muslim Thought in the Age of al-Ḥākim bi-ʼAmr ʼAllāh. Translated in Persian by Fereidoon Badreii. Farzan Publishers, Tehran. [In Persian]